Comment on Green Mountain Power’s Rate Cases and How They Are Being Handled by the Vermont Department of Public Service

Vermont’s Public Utility Commission has asked for comments by Nov. 27 on the anonymous information, below, which was sent to the PUC, four media outlets, and VCE.  Submit your comments as “Public Comment” in any of the following cases via ePUC:

Case No. 18-2850, 18-1633, 18-3160, 18-0974




On November 19, 2018, the Vermont Public Utility Commission received an anonymous public comment relating to this proceeding. The parties may respond to this public comment by no later than November 27, 2018. The Commission recognizes that it may be difficult to respond to the public comment without knowing the identity of the author.


Posted in DPS, Energy Planning, Green Mountain Power, PUC, VCE | 2 Comments

Plan V-TV/60: Annette Smith of Vermonters for a Clean Environment on Vermont’s Energy Future

Screen Shot 2018-11-11 at 9.53.38 AM

Join “Vermont Independent” publisher Rob Williams for a conversation with Annette Smith, executive director of Vermonters for a Clean Environment (VCE), on citizen activism, challenging corporate power in our Green Mountains, and Vermont’s energy challenges and possible futures. Find out more and support her work at

Find out more about our 2VR at vermontindependent.NET. Questions? Comments? Ideas? Wish to join the nonpartisan 2VR open source network? Email publisher AT vermontindependent.NET.

Thanks for watching Plan V-TV. Long live the 2nd Vermont Republic.


Posted in Energy Planning | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Vermont Public Utility Commission, Public Beware

Vt. PUC Hearing Officer Threatens Citizens’ Attorney with Removal from Hearing Room, Sept. 20, 2018

This first of three 2+ minute videos is 8 minutes into the hearing on the record on the morning of the first day of the two-day hearing.  It set the tone for the rest of the day and the following day.  

  1. Shot 2018-10-11 at 8.00.28 PM

This exchange between the Hearing Officer and the citizens’ attorney occurred in the afternoon after lunch.  

2. Shot 2018-10-11 at 7.58.50 PM

Later, the pro bono attorney representing pro se parties (Vermont citizens who participated without an attorney except for the two days of this hearing) is reprimanded by the Hearing Officer for “interrupting” the witness.  The attorney had to keep interrupting because the witness was behaving like a hostile witness and wasn’t answering the questions.  The Hearing Officer should have directed him to answer the questions.  Instead, he reprimanded the citizen’s attorney.  A while later the Hearing Officer finally directed the witness to answer the question he was asked, not the question he wished he was asked.

3. Shot 2018-10-11 at 8.01.21 PM

No Vermonter who participates at the Public Utility Commission should be exposed to this kind of treatment.  The state had five attorneys in the room who never asked any questions.  Aside from the Petitioner’s attorney, the only one asking questions was the attorney representing Vermont citizens who the Hearing Officer threatened to remove within the first 10 minutes of the start of the hearing.

Video of the full hearings:


Posted in PSB, PUC, Solar | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Annette Smith: An examination of Vermont’s energy policies

Mar 18 2018

Editor’s note: This commentary is by Annette Smith, who is the executive director of Vermonters for a Clean Environment Inc. She is a member of the Rutland Regional Planning Commission, where she currently chairs the ad hoc energy committee. She has lived off grid in Danby for 30 years, and was named he 2016 Burlington Free Press Vermonter of the Year.

Most Vermonters accept the reality of climate change and support shifting our energy needs towards renewables. But in my conversations with Vermonters I have found that almost no one fully understands the mechanisms that have been put in place to achieve the state’s renewable energy goals. In fact, our energy policies are so complicated and convoluted that even Vermont legislators – many of whom consistently vote in favor of bills purporting to bring the state closer to a goal of 90 percent renewables by 2050 – don’t really understand them.

To help citizens and policymakers make more informed decisions, Vermonters for a Clean Environment has just released a report, Understanding Vermont’s Energy Policies. The report gives an overview of Vermont’s renewable energy policies, and provides context about our place in the regional electric grid. Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

VCE’s Energy Policy Report on the Dave Gram Show, March 14, 2018


Radio Vermont

Screen Shot 2018-03-13 at 9.37.22 AM

Podcast: Play in new window | Download (Duration: 1:46:34 — 97.6MB) | Embed

In the first hour, Annette Smith executive director of Vermonters for a Clean Environment, talks about a report released by her group Monday saying Vermont has been going about the development of renewable energy in all the wrong ways. Then we hear from Austin Davis of Renewable Energy Vermont, who thinks the state is largely on the right track.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

Understanding Vermont’s Energy Policies

Report Shows Vermont Policies Not Achieving Renewable Energy GoalsScreen Shot 2018-03-13 at 9.37.22 AM

Vermonters for a Clean Environment has released a report, Understanding Vermont’s Energy Policies. It describes five current policies, and explains how they are not doing what Vermonters expect regarding energy policy and consumption. The five policies the paper reviews are:

·      Renewable Energy Standard (RES) 

·      standard-offer program

·      net-metering program

·      Act 174’s energy planning process 

·      Arbitrage with Renewable Energy Credits (RECs)

            Most Vermonters accept the reality of climate change and support the transition to renewable energy from fossil fuels; however, if Vermonters truly want better energy policies and outcomes, the discourse and procedures must be comprehensible and honest, with considerably more transparency.  Currently, only the industrial scale developers, utilities, and regulators have a firm grasp on Vermont’s energy policy maze.

            “Most Vermonters would be stunned to know that we have actually seen an increase in carbon emissions due to our current energy policies,” said Annette Smith, Executive Director of Vermonters for a Clean Environment (VCE). “From public discourse to date, it appears most Vermonters do not realize we get little renewable energy from our State’s wind and solar developments, while simultaneously costing ratepayers significantly more money,” Smith added.

            Smith commented that currently, Vermont is meeting energy goals with monetary and paper transactions, not with honesty and transparency in terms of costs, profits and benefits.  Additionally, any transition to renewables has to include less energy consumption.  

            As the report summary states, “The best possible outcomes are achieved when all stakeholders – utilities, developers, regulators, property owners, investors and communities – are well informed partners in transparent and equitable solutions.”

            “VCE’s goal”, says Smith, “is to provide Vermonters with a solid understanding of what they are and are not getting from current policy, and help inform energy policy going forward.”

To read VCE’s report, go to


Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

New Documentary Film about Wind in Vermont

WIND: A Struggle for the Character of Vermont

click on the image to watch the film


Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

LCAR Legislators’ Responses to VCE’s Public Records Act Request

Videos of LCAR Wind Noise Rule Hearings: 6/8/17, 6/22/17, 8/3/17, 10/12/17, 10/26/17.  In total LCAR spent 10 hours and 20 minutes on the PUC’s wind noise rule.

Screen Shot 2017-11-03 at 2.46.02 PMOn October 16, 2017, Vermonters for a Clean Environment filed Public Records Act (PRA) requests with the eight legislators who serve on the Legislative Committee on Administrative Rules.  This was an unusual action for VCE to take because in the past, legislators did not respond to PRA requests.  On Oct. 18, 2017 VCE held a press conference in the Vermont Statehouse announcing the filing of the PRA requests.

We took this extreme (to us) step after sitting through eight hours of hearings before LCAR on the Public Utility Commission’s Wind Noise Rule where most members’ questions were entirely focused on protecting the industry.  The legislative intent in instructing the PUC to conduct rule-making was to produce sound standards that are more protective of Vermonters than the standards previously applied.

We witnessed interactions between industry lobbyists and LCAR members throughout those eight hours of hearings, and decided it was important to shine some sunshine on the relationship between Vermonters’ elected representatives and the wind industry’s lobbyists.

Five members of LCAR chose to take the extra 10 days allowed by law.  Below are the responses VCE received by the Oct. 30 deadline.  The cost was $94.50.  Each of the legislators’ responses are separated by two lines, and there are eight in total, numbered to make it easier to follow.  Separate responses within each legislators’ sections are separated by one line. Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

“Green Energy”, Avangrid/Iberdrola’s Deerfield Wind in Readsboro and Searsburg, Vt., Formerly Critical Bear Habitat

This gallery contains 29 photos.

More Galleries | Leave a comment

Derrick Jensen’s Resistance Radio interview with VCE’s Annette Smith, April 9, 2017

April 9, 2017 @ 7:00 pm

Resistance Radio – Annette Smith – 04.09.17

Annette Smith is executive director of Vermonters for a Clean Environment, an organization she co-founded 15 years ago with Vermont citizens when a large energy project was proposed for her region.  After successfully defeating that project, Annette has worked with Vermonters throughout the state to defeat large quarries, landfills, farms, and other large energy proposals while also improving Vermont’s groundwater protection laws.  Annette has lived off-grid with solar in Vermont for more than 20 years, hand milks a cow, has a flock of chickens, grows most of her own food including citrus in a greenhouse, and seeks change through collaboration when possible and opposition when necessary 

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment